Table 1. PERFORMANCE EVALUATION REPORT CRITERIA
Inferior quality of
Adequate quality of
Acceptable quality
High quality of
Fixed Price
Superior quality of
Quality of Work
workmanship with
workmanship with
of workmanship
workmanship with
workmanship with
Work
substantial number
with limited
excessive number
minor deficiencies
no deficiencies
(40%)
of deficiencies
of deficiencies
number of
deficiencies
Inferior quality of
Adequate quality of
Acceptable quality
High quality of
Indefinite
Superior quality of
workmanship with
workmanship with
of workmanship
workmanship with
workmanship with
Quantity Work
excessive number
substantial number
with limited
minor deficiencies
no deficiencies
(40%)
of deficiencies
of deficiencies
number of
deficiencies
Consistently
Occasionally
Rarely requires
Contractor QC
Effectiveness
Most jobs do not
requires Govt input
Govt input to
requires Govt input
Program effects all
of Quality
require rework, QC
to rework
rework
to rework
rework
Control Program
program very
requirements
unsatisfactory jobs
unsatisfactory jobs
unsatisfactory jobs
(20%)
effective
Meets schedule but
Meets schedule
Sometimes
Frequently misses
Often responds and
Timely Completion
Fixed Price
scheduled time
requires Govt
without reminders
responds and
Work
performs faster
of Work
prodding
frames; requires
performs faster
(40%)
than scheduled
Govt prodding
than scheduled
Often responds and
Meets DO schedule
Meets DO schedule
Sometimes
Frequently misses
Indefinite
performs faster than DO
responds and
time frames
but requires Govt
without reminders
Quantity Work
schedule
scheduled in DO
performs faster
prodding
(40%)
and requires Govt
than DO schedule
prodding
Schedules not
Schedules submitted
Scheduling
Schedules submitted
Schedules submitted;
Schedules submitted;
submitted; DO dates
but not complied with;
meets dates of all
completes work of
(20%)
and usually complied
consistently not met
approved schedules and
DO dates occasionally
with; DO dates rarely
approved schedules and
not met
missed
DO's ahead of schedule
DO's ahead of schedule