Evaluation and Selection Analysis of Security Glazing for Protection Against Ballistic,Bomb, and Forced Tactics

• Evaluation and Selection Analysis of Security Glazing for Protection Against Ballistic,Bomb, and Forced Tactics
• Abstract
• Abstract -Cont.
• Foreword
• Table of Contents
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Table of Contents -Cont.
• Section 1: Introduction
• Ballistic Resistant Glazing
• Security Glazing Planning and Analysis Worksheets
• Required Information
• Organization of Procedures
• Related Instructions
• Figure 1. Planning Procedures Organization
• Figure 2. Analysis Procedures Organization
• Figure 3. Safevue Procedures Organization
• OPNAVINST 5510.1H.
• Section 2: Glazing System Overview
• Monolithic Cross-Sections
• Thermally Tempered Glass
• Chemically Treated Glass
• Wire-Reinforced Glass
• Acrylic
• Laminated Cross-Sections
• Fragment Retention Film
• Thermally Tempered Glass (TTG)
• Laminated and Fused Polycarbonate
• Glass-Clad Ionomer
• Insulated/Air Gap Cross-Sections
• Glazing Tape, Sealant  and Setting Blocks
• Ballistic Resistance
• Anchor Bolt Types
• Embedded Anchor
• Unreinforced Brick
• Table 1. Wall Construction
• Section 3: Aggressor Threats and Tactics
• Categories Not Addressed
• Tools, Weapons, and Explosives
• Section 4: System Analysis
• System Evaluation Procedure
• Figure 6. Process Chart and Description:  System Selection Procedure
• Figure 7. Process Chart and Description:  System Evaluation Procedure
• Selection Attack Analyses Procedure
• Figure 8 .Process Chart and Description:  Selection Attack Analyses Procedure
• Figure 9. Process Chart and Description:  Evaluation Attack Analyses Procedure
• Required Information
• Figure 10. Process Chart: Selection Reconciliation Procedure
• Evaluation Reconciliation Procedure
• Requirements Revision Procedure
• Figure 12. Process Chart: Evaluation Reconciliation Procedure
• Figure 13. Procedure Description: Evaluation Reconciliation Procedure
• Figure 14. Process Chart: Requirements Revision Procedure
• Figure 15. Procedure Description: Requirements Revision Procedure
• Section 5: Ballistic Resistant Glazing
• Figure 16. Process Chart: Ballistic Resistant Glazing Evaluation Procedure
• Table 5. Ballistic Tactic Threat Severity Level Standards
• Required Information
• Figure 18. Process Chart: Cross-Section Ballistic Resistant Thicknesses Procedure
• Figure 19. Description: Cross-Section Ballistic Resistant Thicknesses Procedure
• Required Information
• Ballistic Resistant Glazing Selection Procedure
• Figure 20. Process Chart: Ballistic Resistant Glazing Selection Procedure
• Required Information
• Section 6: Blast Resistant Glazing
• Frame Loads
• Blast Resistant Glazing Evaluation Procedure
• Figure 22. Process Chart: Blast Resistant Glazing Evaluation Procedure
• Required Information
• Blast Resistant Glazing Selection Procedure
• Figure 24. Process Chart: Blast Resistant Glazing Selection Procedure
• Figure 25. Description: Blast Resistant Glazing Selection Procedure
• Section 7: Forced Entry Resistant Glazing
• Required Information
• Figure 26. Process Chart: Forced Entry Resistant Glazing Selection Procedure
• Figure 27. Description: Forced Entry Resistant Glazing Selection Procedure
• Table 17. Lag Bolt Maximum Spacing for Low Threat Severity Level
• Table 22. Minimum Frame Specification for Medium Threat Severity Level
• Forced Entry Resistant Glazing Evaluation Procedure
• Required Information
• Figure 28. Process Chart: Forced Entry Resistant Glazing Evaluation Procedure
• Figure 29. Description: Forced Entry Resistant Glazing Evaluation Procedure
• Section 8: Environmental Analysis
• Polycarbonate Environmental Analysis Procedure
• Laminated Glass Environmental Analysis Procedure
• Required Information
• Section 9: Cost Analysis
• Figure 34. Process Chart and Description:  Cost Estimate Procedure
• Cross-Section Material Cost Estimate Procedure
• Figure 36. Process Chart and Description: Cross-Section Material Cost Estimate Procedure
• Table 29. Glass Cost Factors and Weight per Unit Area (English Units)
• Cross-Section Fabrication Cost Estimate Procedure
• Figure 37. Process Chart: Cross-Section Fabrication Cost Estimate Procedure
• Required Information
• Figure 39. Process Chart and Description:  Frame Cost Estimate Procedure
• Installation Cost Estimate Procedure
• Initial Cost Estimate Procedure
• Figure 40. Process Chart and Description:  Installation Cost Estimate Procedure
• Figure 41. Process Chart and Description:  Initial Cost Estimate Procedure
• Appendix A Process Charts
• Simple Sequence Structure
• Procedural Structure
• Iteration Structure
• Figure A-7. Do While Structure
• Figure A-8. For Structure
• Appendix B- Security Glazing Planning and Analysis Worksheets
• Glazing System Design Criteria Summary Worksheet
• Asset Value /Aggressor Likelihood Worksheet
• Glazing System Tactic and Threat Severity Level Worksheet
• Collateral Damage Assessment Worksheet
• Cross-Section Evaluation Worksheet
• Frame Evaluation Worksheet
• Anchorage Evaluation Worksheet
• Wall Evaluation Worksheet
• Cross-Section Selection Worksheet
• Frame Selection Worksheet
• Anchorage Selection Worksheet
• Wall Selection Worksheet
• Cross-Section Cost Factor Worksheet
• Frame Cost Factor Worksheet
• Installation Cost Worksheet
• Initial Cost Worksheet
• Safevue Data Entry Worksheet
• Safevue Analysis Worksheet
• Appendix C Safevue Procedures
• Figure C-1. Process Chart and Description:  Safevue Evaluation Analysis Procedure
• Glazing Data Preparation for Evaluation Analysis
• Figure C-2. Process Chart and Description:  Data Preparation for Evaluation Analysis Procedure
• Required Information
• Explosives Data Preparation Procedure
• Required Information
• Safevue Startup Procedure
• Data Entry Procedure
• Glazing Data Entry Procedure
• Figure C-8. Process Chart: Glazing Data Entry Procedure
• Explosives Data Entry Procedure
• Figure C-10. Process Chart and Description:  Explosives Data Entry Procedure
• Algorithm Data Entry Procedure
• Safevue Selection Analysis Procedure
• Data Preparation for Selection Analysis Procedure
• Figure C-13. Process Chart: Safevue Selection Analysis Procedure
• Figure C-14. Description: Safevue Selection Analysis Procedure
• Glazing Data Preparation for Selection Analysis Procedure
• Figure C-16. Process Chart: Glazing Data Preparation for Selection Analysis Procedure
• Table C-1. Minimum Thickness Table Selection for Thermally Tempered Glass
• Table C-2. Minimum Thickness Table Selection for Polycarbonate
• Table C-5. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 220-lb TNT
• Table C-8. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (mm) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 230-kg TNT
• Table C-9. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 1000-lb TNT
• Table C-11. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 50-lb TNT
• Table C-13. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident
• Table C-15. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 500-lb TNT
• Table C-17. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 1000-lb TNT
• Table C-19. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 50-lb TNT
• Table C-20. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (mm) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 23-kg TNT
• Table C-24. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (mm) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 230-kg TNT
• Table C-25. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 1000-lb TNT
• Table C-27. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 50-lb TNT
• Table C-32. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (mm) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 230-kg TNT
• Table C-34. Minimum Thickness of Thermally Tempered Glass (mm) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 460-kg TNT
• Table C-35. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 50-lb (23-kg) TNT
• Table C-36. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 220-lb (100-kg) TNT
• Table C-37. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 500-lb (230-kg) TNT
• Table C-38. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 1000-lb (460-kg) TNT
• Table C-39. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 50-lb (23-kg) TNT
• Table C-40. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 220-lb (100-kg) TNT
• Table C-41. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 500-lb (230-kg) TNT
• Table C-42. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 1000-lb (460-kg) TNT
• Table C-43. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 50-lb (23-kg) TNT
• Table C-45. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 500-lb (230-kg) TNT
• Table C-48. Minimum Thickness of Polycarbonate (in.) to Survive Incident Overpressure from 220-lb (100-kg) TNT
• Plate Data Preparation Procedure
• Results Analysis Procedure
• Figure C-19. Process Chart and Description:  Results Analysis Procedure
• Modifying a Cross-Section to Avoid Failure
• Modifying a Cross-Section to Avoid Overdesign
• Appendix D. Risk Analysis
• Planning Procedure
• Information Sensitivity
• Information Sensitivity -Cont.
• Section D-2. Assets
• Required Information
• Figure D-3. Process Chart:  Assets Procedure
• Primary Asset Value Assessment Procedure
• Figure D-5. Process Chart and Description:  Asset Identification Procedure
• Figure D-6. Process Chart: Primary Asset Value Assessment Procedure
• Figure D-7. Description: Primary Asset Value Assessment Procedure
• Criticality to the Military's Mission
• Asset Replaceability
• Relative Value for AA&E
• Relative Value for Controlled Medical Substances
• Relative Value for Other Assets
• Relative Value for People as Assets
• Secondary Asset Value Assessment Procedure
• Required Information
• Table D-13. Secondary Asset Value Rating
• Section D-3. Design Basis Threat
• Identification of Likely Aggressors Procedure
• Identify Likely Aggressor
• Figure D-11. Potential Aggressors Selection Table
• Likelihood of Aggression Procedure
• Figure D-12. Process Chart:  Likelihood of Aggression
• Asset Profile
• Table D-15. Asset Usefulness to Aggressor Factor Applicability Table
• Usefulness for Assets with Direct Application to Aggressor's Goals
• Usefulness for Assets with Publicity Value
• Local Incidents in the Past
• Nearby Incidents in the Past
• Asset Accessibility
• Table D-21. Potential for Future Incidents
• Table D-22. Asset Accessibility Factor Applicability Table
• Table D-24. Accessibility of Unit Level Storage of AA&E
• Effectiveness of Law Enforcement
• Deterrence
• Likelihood Rating
• Required Information
• Applicability of Indicated Threat Severity Levels
• Figure D-14. Process Chart: Applicable Tactics and Severity Levels Identification Procedure
• Figure D-15. Description: Applicable Tactics and Severity Levels Identification Procedure
• Figure D-16. Potential Tactic Selection Table
• Tactics Consolidation Procedure
• Figure D-18. Process Chart and Description:  Tactics Consolidation Procedure
• Table D-30. Threat Parameters
• Section D-4. Level of Protection
• Figure D-19. Process Chart: Level of Protection Procedure
• Collateral Damage Assessment Procedure
• Required Information
• Figure D-21. Process Chart: Collateral Damage Assessment Procedure
• Figure D-22. Description: Collateral Damage Assessment Procedure
• Table D-32. Asset Categories with Collateral Damage Potential
• Figure D-23. Process Chart: Collateral Damage Threat Severity Level
• Figure D-24. Description: Collateral Damage Threat Severity Level
• Appendix F Examples
• Facility Characteristics
• Table E-1. Description of Primary Assets
• Table E-2. Actions for Example Number 1
• Figure E-1. DCS Worksheet for Example Number 1
• Asset Value/Aggressor Likelihood Worksheet
• Asset Value/Aggressor Likelihood Worksheet -Cont.
• Asset Value/Aggressor Likelihood Worksheet -Cont.
• Asset Value/Aggressor Likelihood Worksheet -Cont.
• Asset Value/Aggressor Likelihood Worksheet -Cont.
• Example Number 2:  Design Basis Threat Procedure
• High-Ranking Military Personnel
• Administration Staff
• Back Up Generator
• Table E-4. Actions for Example Number 2, Continued
• Table E-4. Actions for Example Number 2, Continued
• Glazing System Tactic and Threat Severity Level Worksheet
• Figure E-8. DCS Worksheet for Example Number 2
• Figure E-9. TTSL Worksheet for Office Equipment
• Figure E-9. TTSL Worksheet for Office Equipment
• Figure E-11. TTSL Worksheet for Administration Staff
• Figure E-12. TTSL Worksheet for Back Up Generator
• Example Number 3:  Level of Protection
• Figure E-13. DCS Worksheet for Example Number 3
• Example Number 4:  System Analysis
• Table E-6. Blast Design Properties and Results
• Table E-7. Cost Data
• Table E-8. Actions for Example Number 4
• Figure E-14. CSS Worksheet Before Revising Requirements
• Figure E-15. FS Worksheet Before Revising Requirements
• Figure E-16. WS Worksheet Before Revising Requirements
• Safevue Data Entry Worksheet
• Table E-9. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Figure E-18. SA Worksheet for Laminated Glass
• Table E-10. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Table E-11. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Table E-12. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Figure E-19. SA Worksheet for Laminated Polycarbonate
• Figure E-20 SA Worksheet for Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure E-21. SA Worksheet for Air-Gap with Polycarbonate
• Table E-13. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Figure E-22.AS Worksheet Before Revising Requirements
• Table E-14. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Figure E-23. CSS Worksheet After Revising Requirements
• Figure E-24. FS Worksheet After Revising Requirements
• Figure E-25. AS Worksheet After Revising Requirements
• Figure E-26. WS Worksheet After Revising Requirements
• Figure E-27. CSCF Worksheet for Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Table E-15. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Figure E-28. FCF Worksheet
• Table E-16. Actions for Example Number 4, Continued
• Figure E-29. Installation Cost Worksheet
• Figure E-30. Initial Cost Worksheet
• Figure E-31. CSCF Worksheet for Laminated Polycarbonate
• Figure E-32. CSCF Worksheet for Air-Gap with Polycarbonate
• Appendix F- Cross Sections
• Air-Gap
• Figure F-2. 7/8-inch Air-Gap
• Figure F-5. 1-1/4-inch Air-Gap
• Figure F-7. 1-15/16-inch Air-Gap
• Extruded Ionomer
• Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-12. 11/16-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-14. 15/16-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-16. 1-3/16-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-18. 1-3/16-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-20. 1-5/16-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-22. 1-3/8-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-24. 1-5/8-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Figure F-26. 2-1/16-inch Glass-Clad Polycarbonate
• Laminated Glass
• Figure F-29. 2-inch Laminated Glass
• Laminated Polycarbonate
• Figure F-31. 1-1/4-inch Laminated Polycarbonate
• Bibliography
• References
• References -Cont.
• References -Cont.
• Glossary
• Glossary -Cont.
• Glossary -Cont.
• Glossary -Cont.
• Glossary -Cont.
• Index
• Index -Cont.
• Index -Cont.
• Index -Cont.
• Index -Cont.
• Index -Cont.
• Index -Cont.
• Index -Cont.
• Standardization Document Improvement Proposal

Evaluation and Selection Analysis of Security Glazing for Protection Against Ballistic,Bomb, and Forced Tactics